them, “No. Don’t...
them, “No. Don’t do it.” So for a while we were fighting, tooth and nail, crazy
eBay people: “Go away, we don’t want you.”
Eventually we realized that these guys were begging to be our users. We
had the moment of epiphany, and for the next 12 months just iterated like crazy
on the website version of the product, which is today’s PayPal. Sometime by late
2000, we killed the handheld one because we peaked out at 12,000 users. They
were still using it a little bit, and they were really upset when we killed it. They
said, “You were about the handheld transactions, not about this web stuff.”
We’re like, “No, we’re pretty much about the web stuff.”
Livingston: How many users did you have for the website when you killed the
handheld product?
Levchin: I think we must have been 1.2 . . . 1.5 million users. It was an emotional
but completely obvious business decision.
Livingston: When did you first notice fraudulent behavior?
Levchin: From day one. It was pretty funny because we met with all these
people in the banking and credit card processing industry, and they said,
“Fraud is going to eat you for lunch.” We said, “What fraud?” They said, “You’ll
see, you’ll see.”
I actually had an advisor or two from the financial industry, and they said,
“Get ready for chargebacks. You need to have some processing in place.” We
said, “Uh huh.” They said, “You don’t know what a chargeback is, do you?”
Livingston: So you didn’t foresee this fraud?
Levchin: I had no idea what was going to happen.
Livingston: But you weren’t too surprised?
Levchin:We tried to attack the system for ourselves, like a good security person
would. How can you cheat and steal money and do whatever? We made some
provisions from day one to prevent fraud. We prevented all the obvious fraud,
and then, I think 6 months into it, we saw the first chargeback and were like,
“Ah, one per week. OK.” Then it was like an avalanche of losses; 2000 was basically
the year of fraud, where we were just losing more and more and more
money every month. At one point we were losing over $10 million per month in
fraud. It was crazy.
That was when I decided that that was going to be my next challenge. I
started researching it, figuring out what could be done and attacking the problem.
Livingston: So you made a conscious decision to attack this problem?
Levchin: It was actually sort of a side effect. We had this merger with a company
called X.com. It was a bit of a tough merger because the companies were
really competitive—we were two large competitors in the same market. For a
| ← we needed two | while, Peter took → |